Hilary Mantel wasn’t pretty

And how that simple fact exposes my own hypocrisy to me.

Hilary Mantel – and I wouldn’t write this were she alive! – was not pretty. That’s not to say she wasn’t attractive: with big blue eyes and dimpled cheeks she certainly had some cute features, and her wisdom and vivacity shine through in her words and in good portraits of her. She was happily married for a good number of years and adored – and respected – by her husband and fans alike. Flattering photographs from her younger days play up her best features and she seems to have grown into a ‘self’ who understand how she wanted to be perceived… but she wasn’t pretty. Makeup artists don’t seem to know what to do with her and she always seems somewhat trepidatious on camera, like the sitting has gone on too long and she’s cautiously worried about the outcome. So, Hilary Mantel – one of the greatest authors of our time, a woman I publicly admire and model myself after – was feminine, without being pretty.

Who gives a fuck?

Hilary won the Booker Prize twice, and her work is provocative, well-researched, boundary-pushing, and beautiful in its craft as well as its prose. She was, allegedly, kind and cheeky and obsessive, and full of mentorly advice. Her books will live forever and she left so much personality on the page, in so many different forms, that I find it hard to believe a reader wouldn’t fall in love with her. These are the reasons that Hilary Mantel is somebody I admire greatly – I luxuriate in her prose, her sense of history, her presentation of deeply human characters. I want to be like her.

It reassures me that Hilary Mantel was not pretty. I find it honest to acknowledge that the performance of womanhood we all participate in does not create equal results, that some people simply have thin hair or an overbite or are fat, and it doesn’t in the remotest corner of my mind factor in to how I feel about them… unless that person is myself. I fear that if I come across awkward or ugly in photographs it will negate any talent I might possess and condemn me to mediocrity. I fear that I am ‘woman’ first and ‘person’ second and will be judged accordingly – that is, am I affable, gentle, acquiescent, and, above all, pretty? I fear being associated with all the negatives society tars women with if I step outside of the box of aesthetic good taste as determined by my career intentions – and it is women[1], as we all know that if Stephen Fry was seen wearing Nike Airs there wouldn’t be anything like the backlash there was to Theresa May’s tasteful and conservative leopard-print shoes. Getty Images has a stock photo category for those specific shoes[2]. To be engaged in public life is to accept the potential for ostracisation and trashing for simply diverging from normal, expected patterns, and as a woman your mere existence pushes you into public life. Men at cash machines own your body enough to comment, students will take your footwear into account when they consider your teaching skills, and in a transphobic world having a body that looks non-standard can be considered an act of violence against the social contract. I fear that I am losing my grip on the performance of Woman as I age, that I am losing time to be ‘great’, that unless I am a good Woman – that is, pliant, pleased, pretty – I will not be allowed success.

Pretty Privilege is real, and quantifiable, but I find that I can arrest my (admittedly rational) phobia of being deemed insufficient by circling my mind back to Hilary. Would anybody whose opinion I respect say anything akin to ‘Oh Hilary Mantel might be a good author but isn’t her hair awfully thin?’ It’s preposterous, and I am grateful that Hilary – with her big blue eyes and wicked, unposed smile – shines a light on my fear of not being taken seriously because I am the ‘wrong sort’ of woman, or not performing well enough as Woman, or not trying hard enough for my Womanhood to be uncontested and successful. Pretty Privilege can be counteracted. It is the norm, but we can be exceptions. I truly believe that many of the benefits of Pretty Privilege is that the hidden labour of Womanhood can be counteracted by being naturally pretty, but we can combat Pretty Privilege also by ceasing to perform and using our energy on our work, like men do. By refusing to relinquish womanhood without being Woman takes some audacity – the onlookers will doubtlessly be unsatisfied, but how others perceive you cannot stop you engaging with and writing about an embodiment of womanhood.

Hilary was a woman, and her work displays it. She gives female characters a roundness and an agency, even writing about stories they are not traditionally associated with (like the French Revolution [3]) and her relationship with the rage and pain of womanhood is on brazen display in her work [4]. One could never strip her of her female identity, and she grew in strength as she understood wider experiences of female life. Hilary wrote her whole life, but she entered a renaissance in age. How could she not? A craft she had been honing had paid off and she was widely respected. She became a Dame who moved in royal circles and used that to fuel her writing and understanding of others – again, bringing a uniquely feminine understanding to what it means to be a pretty woman in the public eye [5]. She demands respect not simply as an author, but as a female author, for how she wields herself and demonstrates herself and performs though her art, rather than through her personhood. She wore dresses and lipstick, styled her hair, chose velvet and pashminas as an act of… nothing. She simply was a woman.

One cannot respect Hilary Mantel’s art without respecting her personhood since they are inextricably linked. Once you see it like that, a lack or respect for the author becomes a lack of respect for womanhood. Why would you be presented with a stimulus and crane your neck, contort yourself backwards, to see what the person who presented it to you looks like? Are you disgusted by women with wrinkles, by fat pop stars, by people who choose to spend their time on something other than the art of projecting a Selfhood? It’s a thought I’ve found freeing. I am not disgusted by Hilary Mantel’s lack of conventional good looks. Quite the opposite: I am unnerved by the uniform smoothness of women in public life, the unerring prettiness of women allegedly chosen for their competence, the disturbing physicality of the female form. I can respect the choice of any woman to fight on the multiple fronts of skill and beauty – god knows I feel myself that it is effective even as I find it distasteful and counter-intuitive – but in my appreciation of Hilary Mantel I can recognise that it is hypocrisy and social conditioning that makes me feel insufficiently Woman without the external mode that maketh.

We must also remember that these exceptions are only in public life and, although we are beamed with seemingly endless images of feminine perfection, that is not the true status of humanity at large: women everywhere have better things to do than perform femininity at great expense and cost of time. If your maths teacher is fat, so what? If your barista isn’t wearing makeup, so what? If your bus driver has thin lips so what? If an author isn’t pretty, who gives a fuck? And I truly mean that as a question: what sort of person would care? How are you even thinking about that? How far does it go – do Black bodies, disabled bodies, old bodies disturb you? The people I love are rejected by you based on their physical form? Humanity is predicated on performance in your eyes? My respect for Hilary Mantel allows me to see through the veil of respectability that lies upon the expectations women have for themselves in this mess of a society and reminds me that my insecurities and frailties of constitution are nothing next to traits I truly admire.

[1] I am not a PoC but I do believe it applies to these other demographics – my heavily-tattooed Chinese friend is racially abused by people who think she is not ‘proper’ despite her being a born-and-bred East Londoner; a Black man in a tweed blazer would run the risk of being called a coc*nut (I really feel like this is a slur and I’m not comfortable using it, but I also feel like its what would be said, but also the c-word is a different thing entirely)

[2] it only has eight pictures, but that is sort of the point IMO – the woman wore some work appropriate LK Bennett shoes and it became such a big deal a stock photo site had to CROP OTHER PICTURES OF HER TO ONLY HER FEET. I don’t agree with her politics but for the love of god I will defend her right to wear shoes that were probably suggested by an aide anyway.

[3] Lucile Desmoulins is my favourite character in A Place of Greater Safety.

[4] Beyond Black is a painful exploration of the atavistic horror that is the female experience. I direct you to read it, but it is a dark read with sexual, physical and psychological violence against women (and animals).

[5] if you haven’t read Royal Bodies, her ‘controversial’ take on Kate Middleton and how she shouldn’t be scrutinised, go to the LRB website NOW.

To get this article, and others, as physical media, subscribe now.

On This Topic:

To-Do:

  • Start using a hair mask / getting more regular trims – time to age gracefully into the glamorous old-lady scholar I know is inside me
  • Decide what to wear for various birthday visits
  • Post more pics to IG!! Promote your dang work!!

Today’s Culture:

  • I am 54% of the way through Middlemarch and I don’t think I’ll know what I think until the end.
  • I haven’t listened to much music because Middlemarch is so long but Josie Edwards has made it onto my playlists
  • There’s a bunch of art exhibits I want to see at the moment – Peggy Guggenheim at the RA, Pre-Raphaelites at the Fitz… I might be emerging from my ‘books only’ bubble.

Leave a Reply

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑